# in operator names to be removed22 Feb 2014
This post was imported from blogspot.Originally I decided that in Loyc trees, '
#' would be a prefix that meant "special" or "keyword". So reserved words or language constructs would be represented as identifiers that start with '
Operators seemed special, so I also decided that operators would have the same prefix:
#>>, etc. I've changed my mind, though, for two reasons:
- I no longer think operators are so special. LES and some other languages have an infinite number of potential operators and they're treated identically to normal functions, apart from their syntax.
- No language I know of uses the specific prefix '
- Most importantly, the syntax for naming operators turned out to be cumbersome: because an operator name like
#+generally cannot be used directly as an identifier in most languages, some sort of escaping mechanism is needed. In LES and EC# you have to write, in general,
@`special identifier`(not just
`special identifier`because the latter is treated as an operator, not an identifier). Therefore the identifier
@#+also works in LES), which is a bit cumbersome and (more importantly IMO) creates a teaching challenge: I have to explain both what
#is for and also what
@and the backticks are for, and the student must remember not to mix up
#. Plus, when someone encounters LES or EC# code for the first time it'll be harder to guess what
@`#+`means compared to
@`+`, and Google won't help ("Your search - @`#+` - did not match any documents.")
(+), and Nemerle
@+. In all of these cases the additional characters near
+can be understood as an escaping mechanism, so that the actual identifier name is simply
Therefore, I will soon dedicate a day or two to removing the hash characters from the beginning of all operators in both LES and EC#. Possibly, I'll remember to update the documentation too. We'll see.
Update (June 2014): The removal process was completed.